Ash vs Oak Flooring: Pros and Cons Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to choosing the perfect flooring for your home, two popular hardwood options emerge – ash and oak. Both offer a distinct set of characteristics, making it essential to understand their differences to ensure an informed decision.

Ash flooring, known for its light color and straight grain, offers a modern and appealing aesthetic. Oak flooring, on the other hand, boasts a classic look, durability, and a wider variety of colors and patterns. In this article, we will provide a comprehensive comparison of ash and oak flooring, covering key aspects such as appearance, functionality, and cost.

Physical Properties

In this section, we will explore the physical properties of ash and oak flooring, including hardness, color, and grain patterns.


Ash and oak have distinct differences in hardness, which are measured on the Janka scale. The higher the number, the harder the wood.

Wood TypeJanka Scale Value
Ash Flooring1320
Oak Flooring1360

Oak flooring is harder than ash flooring, with a Janka scale value of 1360 compared to ash’s 1320. This means that oak is slightly more durable and more resistant to wear and tear.


The color of both ash and oak flooring varies depending on the specific type of wood and the finishes applied. However, there are some general distinctions:

  • Ash flooring typically has a lighter color, often described as pale blonde or light brown with hints of white.
  • Oak flooring usually has a warm, golden-brown color, which can vary from medium to dark brown depending on the specific species and finish.

Grain Patterns

The grain patterns of ash and oak flooring are also distinct:

  • Ash flooring features straight grains and moderately pronounced patterns, giving it a clean, contemporary appearance.
  • Oak flooring has prominent and varied grain patterns with a combination of straight lines, swirls, and knots, providing a traditional, rustic look.

The physical properties of ash and oak flooring can significantly impact their appearance and durability, so it’s essential to consider these factors when making a decision.

Durability and Maintenance

Resistance to Wear and Tear

Ash and oak flooring are both known for their durability and resistance to wear and tear. The Janka hardness scale measures the hardness of wood, with higher numbers representing a harder surface. White oak measures 1,360 and red oak measures 1,290, while ash is slightly harder at 1,320.

Both types of wood are suitable for high-traffic areas, but ash’s slightly higher hardness may offer slightly better resistance to dents and scratches.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Both ash and oak hardwood floors are relatively low-maintenance and easy to clean. Regular sweeping or vacuuming can help remove dirt and debris, preventing scratches on the surface.

For a deeper clean, use a soft, damp mop or a hardwood floor cleaner specifically designed for use on urethane-finished wood floors. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaning tools, as they can damage the finish.

Regarding refinishing, both ash and oak floors can be sanded and refinished multiple times. However, oak’s pronounced grain may require slightly more effort to sand evenly than ash’s more uniform grain pattern.

Cost Comparison

Initial Investment

Ash and oak flooring have different initial costs. Let’s compare their price range and factors affecting it:

  • Ash flooring: typically ranges from $6 to $8 per square foot.
  • Oak flooring: commonly priced between $5 and $10 per square foot.

The price varies based on factors such as wood grade, plank width, and finish options. Wider planks and higher grade wood generally cost more.

Long-Term Value

In terms of long-term value, both ash and oak have qualities that make them desirable flooring options:

  • Durability: Both woods have a long lifespan when properly maintained. Ash is slightly harder than oak, with a Janka hardness rating of 1320, while oak has a rating of 1290.
  • Refinishing: Both ash and oak can be refinished multiple times, depending on the thickness of the wood.
  • Resale value: Oak is more popular, and it might have a slightly higher resale value. However, both wood types can positively affect the resale value of a home due to their timeless appeal.

Room Suitability

A significant factor to consider while choosing the right flooring is its suitability for different rooms in your house. Let’s take a look at how ash and oak flooring perform in various settings:

RoomAsh FlooringOak Flooring
Living RoomExcellentExcellent
BasementPossible with engineered flooringPossible with engineered flooring

As evident from the table, both ash and oak flooring excel in living rooms and bedrooms. They perform well in kitchens but are not recommended for bathrooms due to moisture concerns. Engineered ash and oak flooring can be suitable for basements, as they can handle some level of moisture and temperature fluctuations better than solid wood flooring.

Wrap Up

In summary, both ash and oak flooring have their advantages and drawbacks.

Ash flooring offers a lighter color, unique grain pattern, and better resistance to impact. On the other hand, oak flooring is more available, has versatile staining options, and a well-established reputation.

When choosing between the two, it’s important to consider factors such as cost, durability, and appearance. Ultimately, the decision should suit the specific needs and design preferences of the space.

Leave a Comment